"The best Neapolitan you'll find between Hamilton and Montréal. That oven, that dough, that crust-char. Eat the Pizza della Casa with an Aglianico and thank us later."
A small wood-fired shop on College Street doing proper Neapolitan pizza the way Luca learned it on Via dei Tribunali — slow-fermented dough, San Marzano, fresh fiordilatte, a 90-second bake at 485 °C. Nothing more, nothing less.
The oven came first. Everything else was built around it.
When Luca took over what had been a hardware store in early 2020, the only fixed rule was that there would be one forno a legna, a proper wood-burning oven, right in the middle of the room. Not gas, not electric, not a gas-assisted hybrid. A Valoriani shipped in fragments from Reggello, Tuscany, rebuilt over four weekends by a bricklayer from Woodbridge who'd been laying ovens in Ontario Italian-clubs since 1979.
It runs at 485 °C on the hearth, give or take ten degrees depending on the day, and we feed it beech from Haliburton. A Neapolitan pizza bakes for 75–90 seconds. That's the non-negotiable. Any slower and you dry out the dough, kill the puff on the cornicione, never get those leopard spots. Any hotter and the cheese scorches before the crust is ready. Ninety seconds is a number you earn — it took Luca twenty months in Napoli to reliably hit it.
If your oven can't hit 450 properly, whatever else you do with the dough or the tomatoes is academic. You're not making Neapolitan. You're making something else that maybe has tomatoes and cheese on it. — Luca, to a journalist from Toronto Life, October 2023
We kept the menu small on purpose. Six pizzas means every dough ball is accounted for. Two rotating seasonal pies — Pizze della Settimana — let the kitchen play.
Full menu including antipasti, pasta of the day, dolci and wine — on the menu page.
Luca Varese was born in North York, grew up on minor-league hockey and his mother's Friday cappelletti. From 2014 to 2017 he worked at BMO Capital Markets analysing Canadian mid-cap energy equities. He was pretty good at it. He also ate a lot of bad office lunch pizza.
In the summer of 2017 he burned out — quietly, without drama — and booked a one-way flight to Napoli. He thought he'd stay a month. He ended up working under Gino Sorbillo on Via dei Tribunali for twenty-one months, starting by washing dishes and leaving as a pizzaiolo who could hit a 90-second bake six out of seven times. The pay was roughly a tenth of what he made in Toronto. He was happier.
He came back in late 2019 with a plan to open something small on College Street. The lease on 892 signed on 14 March 2020. Four days later the first lockdown began. He opened anyway — only for takeout, only on Fridays and Saturdays — on 18 April 2020. The pizza was good, word moved quickly, and by the time restaurants could reopen dining rooms in September Luca had already built the shape of what this place was going to be.
His partner Sofia Marchetti, a Neapolitan artist who had been his classmate at language school in Napoli, moved over in early 2021. She runs the front, handles the wine list, and most weeks she's the person answering the phone when you call to ask whether we're open on Monday. (We're not. We've been closed Mondays since day one and we're not changing that.)
A 3.1 km radius from the shop, run by our own two riders. We don't work with third-party apps — the pizza doesn't hold up in those carriers, and the commissions make the price unfair.
Zones: Little Italy · Trinity Bellwoods · Kensington · Dufferin Grove · Palmerston · The Annex south of Bloor · Christie Pits · Parkdale north · Ossington · Crawford (west of Bathurst)
Minimum order $25 · Delivery fee $4 · Typical time 35–45 min · Rush Fri/Sat evenings 50–60 min
"The best Neapolitan you'll find between Hamilton and Montréal. That oven, that dough, that crust-char. Eat the Pizza della Casa with an Aglianico and thank us later."
"Varese is serious about his oven and serious about his fiordilatte. The room is small and unshowy. The bill comes out reasonable. The pies come out right."
"Toronto's pizza scene has never been this strong, and Boston Piizze is currently the heavyweight. Book ahead for Friday nights — walk-in waits run to 45 minutes."
Orders placed before 8:30 PM land before the oven closes. After that it's pickup only.
Start an order